Gen X’ers: Travel back with me to the early 1980s and recall the likes of Van Halen, Duran Duran, and Madonna at their commercial peaks. Now imagine that after they wrap up a sold-out worldwide stadium tour, they return to the studio and eight months later release an album that will go triple platinum.
Before they can tour in support of that new album, though, a global pandemic hits. Now they hunker down and get busy enough in the studio to put out three more platinum-plus albums of wholly new material, and they re-record, update, and polish unreleased material for two previous highly successful albums (let’s say “Diver Down” and “Van Halen II” or “Rio” and “Seven and the Ragged Tiger” or “Like A Virgin” and “Like A Prayer” ).
So now what we’re looking at when it’s tour time again are four completely new albums’ worth of Van Halen/Duran Duran/Madonna material, plus new and updated music from two more albums, all piled on top of about four years without any appreciable number of live performances from any of them.
You don’t think we would have absolutely and unapologetically – and justifiably – gone out of our collective minds?
That’s what Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour has been – with the added bonus of another entirely new album recorded and released during the tour. And since it’s coming to a close this weekend in Vancouver, I’ve been thinking about how lucky I was to have seen it.
This adventure began nine Christmases back.
At this point, my daughter Kelsey was already an established Taylor Swift fan. I remember hearing “Teardrops on My Guitar” around our house, and how strongly it evoked middle-school me similarly playing Dennis DeYoung’s “Desert Moon” repeatedly. When Fearless came out, “Love Story” and “You Belong with Me” were kind of inescapable. But it wasn’t until Red and the beginnings of Swift’s shift to a more pop sound that I started singing along to the likes of “22” and “I Knew You Were Trouble.” (Yes, shocking, I know: John enjoying songs with synthesizers and electronic pop elements. Surprise, surprise.)
And then 1989 hit, and it was all over for me. Synthpop? Influenced by the likes of Peter Gabriel and Annie Lennox? Titled after a pivotal year in my own life? Sign. Me. The. Fuck. Up.
Still, it wasn’t immediate. The album came out in mid-2014, when Kelsey was a senior in high school and planning for college. She graduated in spring 2015, and looking back, neither of us can quite figure out how and why the entire 1989 World Tour kind of passed us by. (To be fair, there was a lot going on in our lives at the moment, and big-ticket concert spends were few and far between.) Anyway, Kelsey went off to Eastern Michigan University that fall, and when she came home for Christmas, we surprised each other with 1989 on CD. (Jenn knew it was going to happen. She took this picture.)

1989 lived in my car. I listened to it at least twice daily during my commute. Anytime Kelsey was home, she’d ride with me even on short trips for what she called “Taylor Time.”
Then seven years went under the bridge like time was standing still. (Yes, I did that on purpose. If you get the reference, you should probably have had your colonoscopy.)
Flash forward to November 2022, five Taylor Swift albums later. Kelsey lives in New York and we’re on the phone and online and on edge while she and Jenn are waiting to see who can get Eras Tour tickets first. Kels gets three tickets – Jenn has become a fan by this point as well – for the May 13, 2023 stop in Philadelphia.
Christmas, 2022 – Kelsey has these shirts made for us:

That spring weekend, Jenn and I drove to Swarthmore, Pennsylvania, and Kelsey took the train down from New York. The day of the concert, we parked in the stadium lot four hours early, napping and eating and walking around and trading friendship bracelets with people. It rained on and off, but cleared up before showtime.
Our seats were at the side of the stage, so even though we didn’t get a full view of the big set pieces, we got to see Taylor’s “custodian cart” come in and she looked up at our section and waved when she left backstage after the concert had ended.
In between were 3+ hours of standing and dancing and cheering the whole time in awe of the unfolding and unforgettable spectacle. Even with the limitations of our vantage point, it was a breathtaking time. And look, Taylor Swift isn’t even my favorite musician. Top five, sure – she means a lot on a personal level thanks to the fandom I share with my daughter, and she’s constantly growing and evolving and pushing her music and songwriting and performances into new territories. And I’ve been incredibly fortunate to have seen some great concerts over the years, from Nine Inch Nails as an opening act in 1990 to David Bowie to Ramones to The Cure and (finally and after decades) Pet Shop Boys. Point being that there is music which has meant more to me over the years, and I have seen amazing musicians and music on stage – but in terms of complexity of production, stagecraft, endurance, and sheer fucking entertainment? I had never seen anything like this.
We got a bonus song in the form of a “Nothing New” duet with Phoebe Bridgers, and the surprise songs in that night’s acoustic set were “Forever & Always” and “This Love,” which meant I got another 1989 tune live. (For those of you who pay attention to such details, ours was also the show during which Taylor chastised a security guard for harassing a fan without missing a beat of “Bad Blood.”)

And besides all that, I got to see my daughter experiencing heartfelt, soul-exploding joy. And I got to see my wife wet-eyed and belting out words that cut deep and healed at the same time. We all shared this fantastic dream on a warm spring night in Philadelphia, and it was everything.
Then this past February a few days after Taylor announced a new album, Kelsey called me one day and said, “Hey, what are you doing November 22nd?”
Me: “I don’t know: Is that the the Friday after Thanksgiving? Let me che-”
K: “Whether it is or not, I figure you’re going to be in Toronto, because I just got us a deal on two floor seats to see Taylor again.”
No. Fucking. Way.
She’s a tenacious kid, mine is. And if the chance had never come up again, it would have been absolutely OK because I know how lucky we were to be able to see one Eras Tour show. But Kelsey didn’t stop seeking another opportunity, and then she found one.
About two months later, The Tortured Poets Department came out, and then about a month after that, we learned that the new album was getting its own completely new set within the Eras shows – so we’d be getting to see a significantly different concert. (Sadly, I learned that this meant she had cut maybe my all-time favorite song from the setlist, “The Last Great American Dynasty.” I made my peace with it.)

Digression: It’s incredibly cool to me that not only were we fortunate to see two separate shows on this tour, I think it’s special that we saw them when and where we did: As crazy as it seems, the Philadelphia show – May 13, 2023 – was only the 21st performance. Toronto (if I mathed right) was number 145 , November 22, 2024. That’s 560 days and 123 performances in between – a lot of time to work and rework and adjust and explore and improvise to keep things fresh while still keeping the complexity of a show like this running smoothly. Oh, and yeah, let’s record a new album and shift entire sets around while we’re at it. I feel like I really got to hit that sweet spot of being able to know generally what was coming and being in the moment and able to stick things in my memory while still not knowing all the beats and details and being excited to see what was new.
Before the concert, someone saw our shirts and gave us these bracelets:

It really was something, being able to see Taylor herself from the floor for most of the show, even if we needed to lean a little from time to time due to a tall fan or two. We were close enough to look over to our right to the next section and see the little girl who got the “22” hat.
The time in between our concerts allowed me to develop a better appreciation for the Fearless and Speak Now songs. (Special thanks to Ebon Moss Bachrach and “The Bear” for giving middle-aged male me specific permission to belt “Romeo save me / they’re tryna tell me how to feel / This love is difficult / but it’s RE-EEAL – FUCKING GOOOO! FUCKING DRIVE – don’t be afraid we’ll make it outta this mess…” And yes, I just rewatched that clip three times.)

Taylor Swift will never know it, but she did an acoustic surprise set just for us. She started with a little spoken intro, then started playing her guitar, and after about 5 or 6 seconds, she stopped and said, “That’s the wrong key.” Anyway, she played the first verse of “Ours,” which was beautiful, and I got some good video of it, and then I stopped recording so I could be in the moment, and then –
“Rebecca rode up on the afternoon train…”
She’s singing “The Last Great American Dynasty.” And while I am suddenly screaming and my stomach is somersaulting, Kelsey turned to give me a huge hug and kind of but not squarely hit me in the face, but I didn’t care because Taylor Swift was singing about having a marvelous time ruining everything and I kind of couldn’t fucking believe it. It was damn near perfect and I am so lucky.

Then Taylor moved to the piano and started singing “Cassandra” – which she had never performed live. And while we’re rolling in that through the first chorus, she eased into “Mad Woman” and it’s the perfect pairing…and then she mixed in “I Did Something Bad” which floored everyone and she basically played these just for my amazing daughter. In those moments, I know what made her kind of but not squarely hit me in the face because she was so excited and happy for me. This was an epic, once-in-a-lifetime performance and I will never forget it.
After the show ended, we were still down on the floor when we heard the little crowd at the back edge of stage right erupt into cheers – and we smiled, happy for them.
















